"Richter sind ja auch nur Menschen." Eine Analyse der Medienwirkungen auf Strafrichter/-innen unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der Onlinemedien



Veröffentlicht März 19, 2019
Philip Baugut Amrei Milch Marcella Moschini


This paper explores media effects on German Criminal Court judges in the age of online communication. Based on the concept of reciprocal effects, which assumes that mass media exert relatively strong effects on the protagonists of coverage, we conducted ten qualitative interviews with judges to explore their consumption, perception, and processing of media content. Findings show that judges strongly followed media reports on their trials, including websites of established journalistic media brands, whereas social media were widely neglected. Media content was mostly criticized and assumed to have relatively strong impact on third persons. Consequently, judges tended to feel anger and loss of control. On a behavioral level, we found situations in which the media can have an impact on a judge’s trial conduct and sentence. These findings point to a collision between the logics of media and criminal trials, which sheds negative light on the mediatization of justice.


Baugut, Philip, Amrei Milch, und Marcella Moschini. 2019. „‚Richter Sind Ja Auch Nur Menschen.‘ Eine Analyse Der Medienwirkungen Auf Strafrichter/-Innen Unter Besonderer Berücksichtigung Der Onlinemedien“. MedienJournal 42 (4):7-32. https://doi.org/10.24989/medienjournal.v42i4.1761.
Abstract 575 | pdf Downloads 24



online media, media effects, Criminal Court judges, mediatization, qualitative interviews